Illness as a Test of Justice: Responsibility and Empathy Toward Those Suffering From Malignant Diseases
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.63356/stes.hum.2026.007Keywords:
belief in a just world, immanent justice, ultimate justice, responsibility, empathy, cancerAbstract
Introduction: Belief in a just world reflects the need to perceive the world as orderly and fair. Immanent justice refers to the tendency to view illness as a consequence of an individual’s prior behaviour, whereas ultimate justice involves the belief that justice will eventually prevail. These beliefs may shape evaluations of people with cancer.
Aim: To examine the relationship between belief in immanent justice and perceived responsibility for illness onset, and between belief in ultimate justice and affective empathy towards patients. A further aim was to examine gender differences in belief in immanent and ultimate justice.
Material and Methods: The study included 144 adult participants from Bosnia and Herzegovina and Serbia. Participants completed an online questionnaire covering demographic and individual characteristics, the Belief in a Just World Scale, vignettes describing men and women with acute myeloid leukaemia and colorectal adenocarcinoma, and ratings of perceived responsibility and affective empathy.
Results: Belief in immanent justice was positively associated with perceived responsibility across all patient categories. Belief in ultimate justice was positively associated with affective empathy towards women with either illness, but not towards men. A significant interaction between justice type and participant gender was found: men scored higher on immanent justice, while women scored higher on ultimate justice.
Conclusion: The findings highlight the role of belief in a just world in shaping judgements of responsibility and affective empathy towards patients. Immanent justice stands out in attributing responsibility, and ultimate justice in empathy towards women, underscoring the importance of attributional processes in understanding attitudes towards people who are ill.