Constitutional Changes in the Process of Judicial Selection in the Republic of Serbia
Keywords:
constitution, judicial power, election of judges, independence, permanence, Republic of SerbiaAbstract
Introduction: Judicial independence represents one of the fundamental constitutional values, which is exercised through the role of judges. The issue of judicial selection becomes particularly important in constitutional systems that provide for the permanence of judicial office. Once a mistake is made in the selection process, it is very difficult to rectify it later, since the grounds for the dismissal of judges are, as a rule, defined very restrictively in order to ensure the permanence of judicial office. By ensuring the independence and permanence of the judiciary, the stability of the constitutional order is also safeguarded.
Aim: The primary objective of this paper is to analyze the constitutional arrangements governing the procedure for the selection of judges. The paper includes an individual analysis of the advantages and disadvantages of the presented solutions. Furthermore, a comparative analysis of the respective solutions is conducted.
Materials and Methods: The primary sources of data used in this paper are legal acts, legal documents, and relevant literature in the field of constitutional law. The collected data were subsequently critically examined, analyzed, and then compared in order to draw as many relevant conclusions as possible.
Results: Judicial reform in the Republic of Serbia represents a complex and long-term process. The 2022 Constitutional Amendments represent the culmination of this reform, as they provide for the independence and permanence of the judiciary. Their primary objective was to reduce political influence over the selection and work of judges. However, they leave room for potential indirect influence by the legislative branch and, through it, by the executive branch.
Conclusion: Given the importance of the judiciary and the need to ensure its independence, particular attention must be paid to the procedure for the selection of judges to judicial office. Judges may be selected by a political body or by a body originating from the judiciary itself. In the Republic of Serbia, the model whereby judges are selected by a judicial council, namely the High Judicial Council, is applied. Therefore, it is of great importance for the state to ensure not only an adequate institutional and legal framework, but also to substantively enable the selection of the best candidates for such highly responsible positions by distinguished legal professionals.