The Q Hypothesis and the Farrer Theory: A Comparative Synoptic Analysis
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.63356/stes.hum.2026.019Keywords:
Synoptic Problem, Q Hypothesis, Farrer Hypothesis, Two-Source Hypothesis, Synoptic Gospels, Redaction CriticismAbstract
Introduction: The Synoptic Problem remains a central question in New Testament scholarship, particularly regarding the literary relationship between Matthew, Mark, and Luke. The hypothetical Q source, proposed to explain material shared by Matthew and Luke but absent from Mark, continues to be debated in relation to alternative explanations, especially the Farrer hypothesis.
Aim: This study aims to evaluate the explanatory strength of the Two-Source and Farrer hypotheses through a comparative examination of selected Greek synoptic passages, identifying which model more convincingly accounts for their textual agreements, differences, and editorial characteristics.
Materials and Methods: The research employs qualitative textual comparison, literary criticism, and redaction criticism. Five selected synoptic comparisons are examined, including John the Baptist’s preaching, the Lord’s Prayer, the parables of the talents and minas, a minor agreement between Matthew and Luke against Mark, and Mark–Q overlap. The analysis considers verbal correspondence, narrative context, textual variation, and possible editorial tendencies, alongside relevant classical and recent scholarship.
Results: The comparisons reveal varying degrees of explanatory strength. The TwoSource hypothesis offers a plausible explanation for substantial agreement within the double tradition, particularly John the Baptist’s preaching. However, the Farrer hypothesis provides a more economical account of certain editorial differences, minor agreements, and Mark–Q overlap by allowing Luke direct access to Matthew. The Lord’s Prayer remains compatible with both models. Overall, the selected evidence indicates a limited comparative advantage for Farrer without conclusively disproving Q.
Conclusion: The findings demonstrate that shared synoptic material does not independently establish the existence of Q. Although both hypotheses remain viable, the Farrer model explains several examined textual phenomena with fewer additional source assumptions. The study contributes a focused, evidence-based comparison while emphasizing the methodological limits of reconstructing an unattested document.